Worshiping around July 4th

Planning worship around Independence Day in the U.S. is tricky in the mainline Protestant church, which for most, today’s worship service and regular church practices arose in the time after WWII, as did the appearance of flags in the church.  I grew up in a small liberal American Baptist congregation that was clear on its separation of church and state and never had flags in the sanctuary, but I remember visiting other friend’s churches and being curious as to why there was an American flag along with a Christian flag in the worship service.

While we are glad to honor our country, we know that first and foremost we are called to honor God.  When I have traveled in other countries and visited other churches, I have never seen their nation’s flag in their sanctuary.  It is unthinkable. But in the U.S., sometimes you are chastised if you don’t have the flag.  It is unique to America, yet many American Christians feel that one must have the flag in the sanctuary, that if we don’t, somehow God will not bless America (and if we ask God to bless America, do we ask God to bless Afghanistan and Canada and Russia as well?)

In my previous congregation that I served, we were fortunate to have many members from countries all over the world, but also we had several families from Canada.  Because Canada Day is July 1st, I started a tradition on the first Sunday of the month, that before the announcements, before worship began, we would sing “O Canada” as well as the “Star-Spangled Banner.”  These songs are not for worshiping God.  These songs are for making us feel patriotic, and really have no place in the worship service.

But there is something about celebrating our diversity, and celebrating the freedom to do so. As much as I didn’t like having the flags in the sanctuary or singing our patriotic songs in worship, when our praise should be directed towards God and not any earthly kingdom, nor ignoring God’s call to people of all nations, there was something genuinely fun and celebratory about singing both national anthems.  It defused the patriotic overtones that God is only on the side of the U.S. that is often found and instead became a celebration of the people.  And once we allowed ourselves to celebrate the people, our nations, our heritage—we were then able to celebrate God’s presence among us all.

We need to continue to separate church and state—and it needs to begin in the worship service.  But separating church and state does not mean doing away with the celebration of our country or countries, our peoples and our traditions—it means that we recognize that is in fact what we are doing.  We are not asking God to specially bless our country because we know God does not do that (even in the prophets it mentions that God has covenants with other countries and peoples).  We are not perpetuating the myth that God is on our side and not on anyone else’s.  We are simply celebrating a tradition of love for our country.  But we need to be clear about what we are doing and why.

Many of the patriotic traditions that have seeped into the worship service occurred in the time after WWII, but those generations are fading and we have forgotten why we do this.  Instead, we sing these songs and have the flags because it has become tradition, and we begin to uphold the myth that somehow America was specially ordained by God out of other nations.  Instead, let us separate out the myth from fact.  Let us celebrate our country, remembering the great diversity of people who live here and who come together for church on Sunday, and then let us worship God, who is God of us all.

May God bless America, and Afghanistan, and all countries, but more importantly, may we be a blessing to others because we remember that God is God of all people.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized by Rev. Mindi. Bookmark the permalink.

About Rev. Mindi

Rev. Mindi Welton-Mitchell is an ordained American Baptist minister married to an ordained Disciples of Christ minister and mother of a child with autism. Mindi grew up in Alaska, lived in Oregon, Massachusetts and Oklahoma, and now lives in the Seattle area. She is a pastor, creator of Rev-o-lution (http://rev-o-lution.org), retreat leader and writer, and a citizen of Red Sox Nation. (Note that her posts are her personal views and do not necessarily represent the views of her congregation).

2 thoughts on “Worshiping around July 4th

  1. An interesting post and an interesting question that has been getting some discussion around the Internet. Thanks.

    On the question of whether I think it is appropriate to have a flag in the sanctuary (or anywhere on the church grounds for that matter), I cannot be more strongly opposed than I am, for a lot of reasons, including those you mentioned.

    But even if we put my insistence that we take the flag out of the sanctuary aside, I think that the discussion of whether the flag goes or stays is missing one conspicuous point: what precisely does the flag represent? It seems as though we take for granted the purported benevolence and righteousness of this nation, as it has been claimed since the country’s founding. How irresponsible, embarrassing and arrogant it is to fail to even mention the horrifying things that have been done under the flag. Besides the fact that this country was founded as an expansionist colonizing empire, which slaughtered and displaced hundreds of thousands of natives, the United States built its wealth on the backs of human slaves. A century of formal apartheid then followed, as Jim Crow drew dehumanizing lines between black and white (powerless and powerful). Women were only given the right to vote in the last 100 years, and the disparities in pay, respect, health and freedom are still present between white, black, Hispanic, male, female, etc. Foreign policy has consistently supported brutal dictatorships in order to preserve the exploitation of poor human beings and their land, required by corporate/state capitalism. We are a nation that used chemical weapons on peasants in southeast Asia, who supported other dictators who did so to their own people, who uses drones to bomb people in foreign countries.

    And of course, I know that like anyone who dares to suggest that our government has committed horrific crimes domestically and abroad, I will be likely called an unpatriotic America-hater. That saddens and puzzles me. I love this country, the people, the culture, the unprecedented societal liberties that we enjoy as much or more than many others. But my conscience, especially as a Christian, cannot permit me to simply pretend that the war crimes the US has committed/is committing, under the pressure of multinational corporate greed, and with our stolen consent don’t exist. And I think that it is evidence of profound blindness and hubris to leave out the dark side of this nation when discussing the presence of a flag in what is supposed to be a holy space where we worship God and pray for forgiveness and salvation.

    So we can leave the flag in or take it out (I hope take it out), but for God’s sake, whatever we do, we MUST acknowledge the history and legacy of an imperial nation alongside the cheers for the freedom we enjoy. I think that the Gospel demands as much, and the oppressed deserve as much.

    • I think we find this theme in the prophets as well with two additional themes: the notion of having corporate (congregational, denominational) accountability for that legacy and God’s resilient nature in calling us back no matter how far we have strayed.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s